Five Star Pizza-Citra

Nestled conveniently on N US Hwy 301 in Citra, Florida, Five Star Pizza-Citra is a delightful pizza restaurant that effortlessly transforms casual dining into an unforgettable experience. Far from your typical pizza joint, this hidden gem specializes in a diverse menu that caters to every craving—from the hearty, oven-baked subs to the indulgently cheesy Deluxe and Philly Pizzas. Whether you're a fan of classic Pepperoni or adventurous enough to try their Bacon Double Cheeseburger or All Meat Pizza, every bite bursts with rich, freshly crafted flavors and a perfectly crisp crust that has customers raving.

The aroma of freshly baked dough and garlic wafts through the air, inviting you to sample their crowd-favorite appetizers like the buttery Garlic Knots, crispy Wings, and Cheezystix that melt in your mouth. Don’t miss the Cinnamon Rolls for dessert—a sweet, warm finish that perfectly balances the savory main courses. For health-conscious diners, their Garden Salad and American or Italian Chef Salads deliver fresh, vibrant flavors and a crisp crunch to your meal.

One of the most magical aspects of dining at Five Star Pizza-Citra is its warm, welcoming atmosphere. Despite being located adjacent to a service station, its friendly staff turns every visit into a personal experience. Customers often highlight the attentive service, especially during busy game nights when servers like Carson add an extra layer of fun by dressing up to celebrate. This genuine hospitality makes the restaurant not just a stop for a quick bite, but a spot where community and comfort blend perfectly.

Many patrons have expressed their surprise and delight at the quality of the food here. Frank Rizzo fondly recalls tackling their giant “Godzilla” size pizza, emphasizing both the impressive portion and the exceptional taste. Similarly, Toby Bear shared how the “absolutely phenomenal” crust and toppings defied expectations for a place that feels like a "hole-in-the-wall." Rebecca R captures it best by saying you can truly taste the freshness of the dough and the perfect crispness that makes each slice a treat.

For those who value prompt service and consistent quality, Five Star Pizza-Citra rarely disappoints. Heather Marie’s comment about the minimal wait times and consistently great food echoes the many returning customers who choose this spot over others. While delivery is not currently available, the warm and inviting setting makes a visit here well worth the trip.

In essence, Five Star Pizza-Citra isn’t just about pizza—it’s about savoring every moment, from the first bite of a gooey Philly Pizza to the last taste of a sweet cinnamon roll. It’s a place where fresh ingredients, dedicated staff, and a cozy vibe combine to create a dining experience that feels like home, even if you’re just passing through.